Get Permission Suttakoti: A clinical study on therapeutic effect of nasya karma in the management of avabhahuka (frozen shoulder) with vishnu taila: Case report


Introduction

Avabhahuka word is derived from combination of two words ava and bhahuka – Ava means viyoga (1) i.e dysfunction or separation1 and bhahuka means arm therefore Avabhahuka means dysfunction in arm. 2

Avabhahuka is a condition caused due to vitiation of vata dosha with sthanasamshraya in the amsa pradesha and does the samkocha of siras leads to manifestation of sira samkocha and bhahu praspandana haratavam which is intimately same to the features of frozen shoulder. 3

Vata dosha is said to be and is considered as chief factor for the maintenance of the physiological maintenance of the body. Factors which leads to provoking of vata dosha results in the instantaneous manifestation of diseases which can even be fatal. The fact is that avabhahuka is one of the vata vyadhi, and is said that vata vyadhi is one among the ashta maha gada. 4

Amsa is described has one of the snayu vikalyakara marma., any injury to these marma can leads to stabdhata.5

Acharya Sushruta has described the avabhahuka vyadhi for the first time in the nidana sthana. Has described siraakunchana (contraction of tendons) is one of the common symptom in avabhahuka. Bahusosha (muscle wasting of arm) and amsabandhanashosha (contraction of shoulder ligaments) are the other symptoms mentioned in different texts. 6

Avabhahuka can be correlated to the frozen shoulder. Frozen shoulder is also known as adhesive capsulitis and is defined as “a condition of uncertain etiology characterized by significant restriction of both active and passive shoulder movement that occurs in the absence of known intrinsic shoulder disorder.7

Frozen shoulder is said to be one of the most common musculoskeletal problem which is seen in orthopaedics.8

The incidence of frozen shoulder ranges between 40 years to 60 years and is found more common in women and in manual worker.9, 10

Frozen shoulder is often seen as primary or secondary to several diseases, such as diabetes mellitus, stroke, local shoulder issue and many others as its etiology is still poorly understood. 11, 12, 13

In case of frozen shoulder the severity of pain worsens during night, insidious shoulder stiffness with near to complete loss of passive and active external rotation of the shoulder. 14

A person who is suffering from frozen shoulder undergoes three painful stages such as:

  1. First stage: painful freezing stage: These stage is with no history of injury, pain and stiffness around the shoulder with nagging constant pain that get worsen at night.

  2. This occurs with the duration of 10 weeks to 36 weeks with little response to NSAID (Non Steroidal Anti Inflammatory Drug).

  3. Second stage – adhesive stage: Where the pain gradually subsides and is observed only at the extereme movements, but stiffness becomes constant and this occurs with 4 months to 12 months of duration.

  4. Third stage – resolution stage: It is observed with spontaneous improvement in the range of movement with duration of 12 months to 24 months. It is with poor quality due to restriction of both active and passive range of shoulder movement.

The treatment modality used for the treatment of frozen shoulder are oral medication, corticosteroids, injections, exercise joint mobilization, distension, acupuncture, manipulation, nerve blocks and surgery etc. 15, 16

Nasya is one of the therapeutic procedures of panchakarma. Panchakarma is one of the specialised therapeutic application of ayurveda system of medicine which kot only cleanses the body but also deliver the drug to the target site.

Nasya is said to be the procedure where the medicated drug is introduced through the nasal route which is delivered to brain thereby acts on whole body, has it is said “ nasa hi shiraso dwaram “ nasya karma helps in delivering drugs to brain by which it helps in alleviating diseases. 17, 18

Nasya is said to be the one of the prime modality of treatment which is used in management of urdhwajatrugata vyadhi.

In ayurvedic system of medicine there are many treatment modality has been explained for the treatment of the avabhahuka among them nasya karma is said to be one of the prime modality of therapeutic treatment which is used in treatment, has it is considered as one of the prime modality in management of urdhwajatrugata vyadhi.

Nasya karma in avabhahuka helps by reducing inflammation, pain, Stiffness of the shoulder joint. Nasya also helps in stimulating the nerve block and stimulates blood vessels in head and neck region, which helps in improving the circulation and nourishment of the affected area which is especially above the clavicle. Nasya also helps in clearing the nasal passage and sinuses, which enhances the breathing and oxygenation to the body.

There are different types of nasya which can be used for the treatment of avabhahuka depending on the severity and nature of the condition of avabhahuka.

Case Study

A 60 years old male patient visited panchakarma OPD of Sindagi Shantaveereshwara Ayurvedic Medical College and hospital Haveri, Karnataka with the following details of patient name – ABC, age –60 years, sex – male, OPD no – 2314923, address– Karjagi.

Chief complaints

Pain from nape of neck radiating right arm and stiffness

Associated complaints

Numbness and weakness in right arm, pain and Stiffness in arm due to which patient is not able to perform his routine works.

Current medical history

The patient was apparently normal before gradually patient developed with pain and Stiffness from the nape of neck radiating to right shoulder joint and arm since 2years. The patient has consulted many hospitals and took allopathic treatment for about 1 ½ year has patient was not satisfied with the treatment, patient consulted to our hospital for further management.

Examination

  1. General examination

    1. G.C - good

    2. BP - 130/80 mmhg

    3. PR –78/min

    4. Pallor – not found

    5. Cterus- not found

    6. Clubbing and cyanosis- not found

    7. Lymphadenopathy – not found

  2. Local examination

    1. Location - neck, right shoulder joint, right arm

    2. Nature of pain - pricking

    3. Duration - continous

    4. Severity - severe and agonising

    5. Radiation – from nape of neck to right arm

  3. Physical examination of right shoulder

    1. Range of movement of shoulder joint – flexion, extension, abduction, adduction, internal rotation, external rotation are restricted and painful.

    2. Inspection – redness, swelling, deformity are absent

    3. Palpation – tenderness is present at right scapular region Temperature is present at right shoulder joint and elbow joint.

    4. Spurling test – positive for right sidee

    5. Compression test - positive for the right side

    6. Appley’s scratch test – positive for right side

    7. Drop arm test – positive for right side

    8. Empty can test – positive for right side

Therapeutic intervention

The patient was admitted in male ward of Sindagi Shantaveereshwara Ayurvedic Medical College and hospital, Haveri, Karnataka, the therapeutic procedure and medical management and treatment protocols was designed after the proper assessment.

Result

The treatmentof avabhahuka with vishnu taila in the form of nasya has effective relief or pacification of pain, stiffness and weakness of shoulder joint movement.

Table 1

Medication and therapeutics are enliste below

Date

Name of therapeutic procedure

Oral medication advised

Day 1

25/5/23

Shiro and greeva abhyanga and greeva basti with masha taila and

Nasya with vishnu taila 8 drops in each nostril

Ekangaveera ras

One thrice a day with ushna jala

Day 2

26/5/23

Shiro and greeva abhyanga and greeva basti with masha taila

Nasya with vishnu taila 8 drops in each nostril.

Ekangaveera ras

One thrice a day with ushna jala

Day 3

27/5/23

Shiro and greeva abhyanga and greeva basti with masha taila Nasya with vishnu taila 8 drops in each nostril

Ekangaveera ras

One thrice a day with ushna jala

Day 4

26/5/23

Shiro and greeva abhyanga and greeva basti with masha taila Nasya with vishnu taila 8 drops in each nostril

Ekangaveera ras

One thrice a day with ushna jala

Day 5

27/5/23

Shiro and greeva abhyanga and greeva basti with masha taila

Nasya with vishnu taila 8 drops in each nostril

Ekangaveera ras

One thrice a day with ushna jala

Day 6

28/5/23

Shiro and greeva abhyanga and greeva basti with masha taila

Nasya with vishnu taila 8 drops in each nostril

Ekangaveera ras

One thrice a day with ushna jala

Day 7

29/5/23

Shiro and greeva abhyanga and greeva basti with masha taila

Nasya with vishnu taila 8 drops in each nostril

Ekangaveera ras

One thrice a day with ushna jala

Day 8

30/5/23

Shiro and greeva abhyanga and greeva basti with masha taila

Nasya with vishnu taila 8 drops in each nostril

Ekangaveera ras

One thrice a day with ushna jala

Day 9

1/6/23

Shiro and greeva abhyanga and greeva basti with masha taila Nasya with vishnu taila 8 drops in each nostril

Ekangaveera ras

One thrice a day with ushna jala

Day 10

2/6/23

Shiro and greeva abhyanga and greeva basti with masha taila Nasya with vishnu taila 8 drops in each nostril

Ekangaveera ras

One thrice a day with ushna jala

Table 2

There is gradual reduction of symptoms

Symptoms

Before treatment

After treatment

Pain

Severe

Mild

Stiffness

Severe

Decreased

Numbness

Present

Decreased

Weakness

Present

Mild

Mobility

Severe painful

Mild pain

Discussion

Nasya with bruhat vishnu taila along with oral medication, sthanika basti and sthanika abhyanga helps in alleviating avabhahuka by alleviating vata.Bruhat vishnu taila is a medicated oil mentioned in Bhaishajya ratnavali vatavyadhi adhikara 307 – 314, cakradatta (22/113 – 120 ). The ingredients present in this oil are

  1. Shalaparni mula – Desmodium gangeriaum

  2. Prishnaparni mula – Uraria picta

  3. Bala mula –Sida cordifolia

  4. Shatavari - Aspargus racemosa

  5. Eranda – Ricinus communis

  6. Brihati mula – Solanum indicum

  7. Kantakari – Solanum xanthocarpum

  8. Putika – Holoptelia integrifolia

  9. Garedhuka – Coix lacryma jobi

  10. Sahachara – Strobilanthusheynianus

  11. Tila taila – Sesanum indicum

  12. Go Ksheera or Aja ksheera

As in the above mentioned drug majority of the drug are of ushna veerya which help pacification of vata dosha. As in case of avabhahuka the disease is caused due to vitiation of vata dosha in amsa pradesha which does Shoshana of kapha dosha. The vishnu taila is said to be the best medicine for the vata vyadhi. As avabhahuka is one of the vataja nanatmaja vyadhi which is having sthana samsraya in the urdhwajatrugata hence vishnu taila which is vatanasaka is used as nasya for avabhahuka which is one of the urdhwajatrugata vyadhi.

Conclusion

Nasya with vishnu taila in madhyama matra of 8 drops to each nostril along with greeva basti and abhyanga with masha tailaas the panchakarma procedures which act as shodhana and poshana i.e nasya karma with vishnu taila helps in the elimination of vitated dosha, basti karma in the form of greeva basti with masha taila helps in alleviating pain, stiffness of greeva pradesha. Shiro and greeva abhyanga helps in relieve and alleviating to patient.

Source of Funding

None.

Conflict of Interest

None.

References

1 

R Radhakantadev Shabdakalpadruma SSanskrit Dictionary 3rd Chaukhamba Sanskrit Series Varanasi199640

2 

M Williams Sanskrit English Dictionary1stOxford University Press 189997

3 

B Radhakantadeva Shabdakalpadruma ShabdakalpadrumaNAG PublishersDelhi1987565

4 

C Datta Deepika Charka samhitha Chaukhamba Orientalia Indriya SthanaVaranasi199489

5 

M Sushruta A Shastri Avarniya Adhyaya Sushruta SamhitaChaukhamba Sanskrit SansthanVaranasi2018680

6 

M Sushrutha A Shastri Pratekmarma Sharira Adhyaya 6/12- 13In Sushruta SamhitaChaukhamba Sanskrit SansthanVaranasi201475

7 

JD Zuckerman A Rokito Frozen shoulder: a consensus definitionJ shoulder elbow surg20112023225

8 

PC Manske D Prohaska Diagnosis and management of adhesive capsulitisCurr Rev Musculoskelet Med 200813-41809

9 

CM Robinson KT Seah YH Chee P Hindle IR Murray frozen shoulderJ Bone joint Surg Br20129419

10 

HS Uppal SP Evan C Smith frozen shoulder, asystematic review of therapeutic optionsWorld J Orthop2015622638

11 

J Cui W Lu Y He L Jiang K Li W Zhu molecular biology of frozen shoulder - induced limitation of shoulder joint movementJ Res Med Sci20172261

12 

W Syabu HM Klinger MV Knoch Prognostic factors and therapeutic options for treatment of frozen shoulder: a systematic reviewArch Orthop Trauma Surg2016136117

13 

V Ryan H Brown CJM Lowe JS Lewis The pathophysiology associated with primary (idiopathic) frozen shoulder: A systematic reviewBMC Musculoskelet Disord2016171340

14 

S Brue A Valentin MF Blad S Werner Mikkelsen Idiopathic adhesive capsulitis of the shoulder: a reviewKnee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 2007158104854

15 

A Schultheis F Reichween W Nebelung frozen shoulderDiagnosis and therapy orthopaedic200437106572

16 

J Lewis Frozen shoulder contracture syndrome - Aetiology, diagnosis and managementMan Ther201520129

17 

RS Ramteke PD Patil A Thakar Efficacy of Nasya (nasal medication) in coma: A case studyAnc Sci Life201635423335

18 

V Patil C Uppin S Gupta V Hiremath Clinical Study To Compare The Efficacy Of Nasya Karma With Shigru Taila And Vidangadya Taila In Vataja Pratishyaya (Allergic Rhinitis)Ausshdhra202411373743



jats-html.xsl


This is an Open Access (OA) journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.

  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article History

Received : 03-08-2024

Accepted : 14-09-2024


View Article

PDF File   Full Text Article


Copyright permission

Get article permission for commercial use

Downlaod

PDF File   XML File   ePub File


Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

Article DOI

https://doi.org/10.18231/j.sajhp.2024.018


Article Metrics






Article Access statistics

Viewed: 335

PDF Downloaded: 49